Tata Motors Stock Analysis: A Roller Coaster Journey of Price Movements

If there’s one stock that truly defines the roller coaster journey of share price movement, it is Tata Motors. It has been a massive wealth creator over the last few years, zooming 18 times from its COVID lows of rs 65. However, it has since corrected by over 40%.

Large-cap stocks rarely experience such deep corrections, making Tata Motors’ volatility unique. Interestingly, this isn’t the first time the stock has suffered a sharp decline. Between 2015 and 2020, Tata Motors’ share price dropped nearly 90%, only to recover strongly later.

This blog explores the key reasons behind Tata Motors’ stock movements, its business model, and whether the stock has bottomed out or faces further downside.

---

Tata Motors Business Model

Tata Motors operates across multiple segments, making it a diversified player in the automobile industry. Its business is broadly divided into four categories:

1. Commercial Vehicles

Tata Motors is India’s largest commercial vehicle manufacturer, producing trucks, buses, and other utility vehicles.

2. Passenger Vehicles (EV & Non-EV)

Tata Motors ranks third in India’s passenger car market, with popular models like Nexon, Punch, and Tiago. It is also the leading EV manufacturer in India.

3. Jaguar Land Rover (JLR)

Tata Motors owns Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), a British luxury car brand acquired in 2008 for $2.3 billion. JLR contributes significantly to Tata Motors’ revenue.

4. Vehicle Financing

Tata Motors operates a Non-Banking Financial Company (NBFC) arm to provide vehicle financing solutions.

Global Presence

• 125+ countries
• 25 manufacturing sites
• 9 R&D centers
• 9,400+ customer touchpoints

In FY24, Tata Motors generated ₹4.38 lakh crore in revenue, with JLR contributing 68.5%, commercial vehicles 18%, and passenger vehicles 12%.

---

Why Tata Motors Stock Fell 90% (2015-2020)?

Between 2015 and 2020, Tata Motors faced multiple challenges, leading to a massive stock decline:

1. Jaguar Land Rover Struggles

• Weak demand in China and Europe
• Brexit uncertainty
• Quality issues affecting brand perception
• Transition from diesel to electric vehicles (EVs) in Europe

2. Slowdown in Indian Auto Industry

• Demonetization & IL&FS crisis
• Liquidity crunch impacting NBFC sector
• Intense competition from Maruti & Hyundai
• Emission norms transition (BS4 to BS6)
  

3. Rising Costs & Debt Burden

• Increase in raw material prices
• High capital expenditures on EV & connected car technologies
• Rising debt from Rs73,000 crore (2015) to Rs1.2 lakh crore (2020)

All these factors led to stagnant revenues, declining profits, and mounting losses, pushing Tata Motors’ stock price down by 90%.

---

Tata Motors’ Massive Recovery (2020-2024)

Post-2020, Tata Motors witnessed a remarkable turnaround, with its stock price skyrocketing 18 times. The key factors behind this resurgence were:

1. JLR’s Strong Rebound

• High demand for models like Range Rover & Defender
• Pent-up demand post-COVID
• Cost-cutting measures improving profitability

2. Growth in Indian Business

• Successful launches of Nexon, Punch, Harrier
• Dominance in EV segment (Nexon EV became India’s best-selling EV)
• Strong growth in commercial vehicle sales post-pandemic
• Debt reduction improving financial stability

3. Positive Market Sentiment

• Indian auto sector rebounded strongly
• Tata Motors’ revenue surged from Rs2.5 lakh crore (2020) to Rs4.37 lakh crore (2024)
• Margins expanded from 7% (2020) to 14% (2024)
• Net profits turned positive, crossing Rs30,000 crore
• Cash flows improved significantly, reaching Rs67,000 crore

Under the leadership of N. Chandrasekaran, Tata Motors focused on innovation, new product launches, and operational efficiency, playing a crucial role in its turnaround.

---

Why Has Tata Motors Stock Fallen 40% Recently?

After an extraordinary bull run, Tata Motors is again facing headwinds. The stock has declined 40% from its peak, with the following challenges:

1. Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) Performance Issues

• Weak demand in China, where premium car sales fell 14% YoY
• Rising inflation in Europe impacting consumer sentiment
• High warranty costs affecting profitability
• JLR’s Q3 net profit declined by 177% YoY

2. Domestic Market Challenges

• Declining commercial vehicle sales (-13.9% YoY in Q2, -8.4% in Q3)
• EV growth slowdown due to rising competition
• Passenger vehicle sales declined 4.3% YoY

3. Weak Q3 Results & Profit Booking

• Tata Motors’ Q3 profits fell 27%, leading to selling pressure
• Increased competition from Maruti, Hyundai, and Mahindra in the EV & passenger vehicle segments
• Promoters reducing their stake, signaling potential concerns

---

What Lies Ahead for Tata Motors?

The big question remains: Will Tata Motors continue to fall, or has it bottomed out?

Future Outlook and Growth Potential

Looking ahead, Tata Motors appears well-positioned for future growth. The company’s commitment to electric vehicles, strategic partnerships, and continued investment in innovation are key drivers. The increasing demand for sustainable transportation and government incentives for EV adoption could further strengthen its position. Additionally, the recovery of JLR’s business and improving financials indicate a promising trajectory.

Short-Term Risks

• China’s economic slowdown impacting JLR
• Rising global inflation & interest rates
• Increased competition in the Indian EV market

Long-Term Growth Drivers

• Tata Motors remains a leader in India’s EV market
• JLR repositioning Jaguar as an all-electric luxury brand
• Upcoming new launches: Harrier EV, Sierra EV, Avinya EV
• Strong cash flow of Rs67,000 crore, providing stability

Valuation & Future Outlook

• Market Cap to Sales Ratio: 0.6
• P/E Ratio: 8x (relatively lower than peers like Maruti & M&M)

While the short-term outlook remains uncertain, Tata Motors has built a strong foundation under N. Chandrasekaran’s leadership. The stock may not correct 80-90% like previous cycles, but near-term volatility will depend on Q4 results and global demand trends.

---

Conclusion

Tata Motors has had a highly volatile journey, experiencing massive corrections and incredible rallies. While the recent 40% drop has raised concerns, the company remains fundamentally strong. Investors should closely monitor its quarterly earnings, JLR’s performance, and EV segment growth before making investment decisions.

What’s your outlook on Tata Motors? Let us know in the comments!