Connect with us

Stock Analysis

MUTHOOT FINANCE vs MANAPPURAM FINANCE A COMPARITIVE STUDY

Published

on

What is financial service sector?

Financial service sectors include companies that perform banking services, investments, money lending, insurance companies, money exchanges and much more. While all these services are provided by government banks or banks authorized by government, there are a set of finance companies that do not fall under NBFC (non-bank financial company) or NBFI (non-bank financial institution). The companies under NBFC do not have full banking license and is not regulated by national/international banking regulators.

Major companies in India that fall under NBFC are

  • Muthoot Finance
  • Bajaj Finance
  • Manappuram finance
  • Tata Capital
  • Aditya Birla capital
  • LIC housing finance
  • Hero Fincorp
  • Sundaram Finance

While in our article today, we will consider two major finance companies among these and review to find out which company outperforms the other:

MUTHOOT FINANCE

When did it come into existence?

Muthoot finance was incorporated as “Muthoot finance private limited”, as a private limited company under companies Act on March 1997. It was converted to public listed company in 2008 and was named as “Muthoot finance limited”. From there on the company has been performing well.

DIVERSIFIED BUSINESS PORTFOLIO:

  1. Muthoot finance limited
  2. Muthoot HomeFin limited
  3. BelStar microfinance limited
  4. Muthoot money limited
  5. Asia asset finance PLC
  6. Muthoot insurance brokers
  7. Muthoot asset management
  8. Muthoot trustee private limited

SERVICES OFFERED

CORE ACTIVITY

OTHER SERVICES

  • Housing loans
  • Money transfer services
  • Business loans
  • Collection services
  • Personal loan
  • Insurance
  • Vehicle loans

HOW DO THEY PERFORM FINANCIALLY?

PARTICULARSFY2023 in MillionsFY2022CHANGE %
TOTAL REVENUE119,750122,382-2%
TOTAL EXPENSES70,52268,2803%
PAT36,69840,313-9%
EPS89.99100.05-10%

The income from interest has decreased, that could be the reason for 2% revenue drop.

The employee benefit expenses have increased contributing to the increase in expense and consequent fall of PAT and EPS.

While there has been a fall in profit, the company in its investor presentation revealed that introduction of digitalized loan repayment options can help the company recover its losses.

MANAPPURAM FINANCE

How did Manappuram come into existence?

Manappuram started off its business in the year 1949 as just money lending and pawn broking on a modest scale. At that period the founder Mr.V.C. Padmanabhan had earned high reputation and integrity among the locals, and the business ran on a capital base of Rs.5,00,000 allowing public to not deposit beyond 25,00,000. After him, when Mr. Nandakumar took over and it started working as Manappuram finance limited in 1992, before going public in 1995. The story says that the company did not have minimum paid up capital for an IPO and the small retail investments from local people helped it go public.

Having discussed so much about the history, let us see what are their present are of expertise:

BUSINESS PORTFOLIO INCLUDE:

  1. Manappuram home finance limited
  2. Manappuram insurance brokers limited
  3. Asirvad microfinance limited
  4. Manappuram comptech and consultants ltd.

The portfolio does not seem diversified when compared with Muthoot finance.

SERVICES OFFERED

CORE ACTIVITY

  • Gold loan

OTHER ACTIVITY

  • Personal loan
  • Business loan
  • Money transfer
  • Vehicle loan
  • Two-wheeler finance

From the services offered, both companies offer similar services.

Having discussed their business, it’s important to understand their financials:

PARTICULARSFY 2023 in MillionsFY2022% CHANGE
TOTAL REVENUE4826.8745875%
TOTAL EXPENSE3120.532837.2210%
PAT1266.271304.54-3%
EPS14.9615.41-3%

While the revenue has increased, increase in total expenses leads to 3% drop in profit and sequentially the EPS.

We can see from the financials that Muthoot finance has a drop in revenue & profits compared to Manappuram finance.

But why is Muthoot enjoying premium valuation over Manappuram finance?

Though Muthoot finance incurred a loss when compared to Manappuram finance in recent financial year, there could be several reasons why it enjoys premium valuation

  1. Muthoot finance attract investors focus because the company forecasts long term growth prospects.
  2. The company in its recent investor’s presentation, has mentioned that it introduced new initiatives such as
    • AI based chatbot with transactional capabilities
    • WhatsApp banking facility with online top-up facility
    • Video KYC and Digital KYC enable for customers digital on boarding.
      And much more.
  3. The company achieved highest ever quarterly gold disbursement of Rs.51, 850 crores in Q4 of FY23, which is a very high achievement for any finance company.
  4. Interest collection stood at Rs.2677 crores, which is also all-time high collection in any Q4.
  5. There are 5,838 new branches with 259 newly opened branches.
  6. While considering the shareholding pattern,
    • The shareholding pattern indicates, the ownership pattern of owners, non-owners of a company and it may also indicate the various sources through which the capital structure is pooled into the business.

From the above share holding pattern, Promoters hold the maximum stake in Muthoot finance compared to Manappuram, which can give a confidence boost up for the investors, as higher promoter stake may indicate high reliability. Sometimes a higher promoter stake alone will not give a clearer picture, so considering other factor also like company’s efficiency, future goals can help an investors decide.

7. Both companies are paying dividends regularly, the dividend yield of Muthoot is 1.89% and that of Manappuram is 2.49%. But the prices are falling for Manappuram which directly affects the dividends issued.

From the article we can understand why Muthoot Finance enjoys premium valuation over Manappuram finance. Diversified portfolio of business, focus on long term growth aspects, introduction of new initiatives, more efficient performance of company in terms of services & expansion of units along with the promoter’s strong component in shareholding pattern can justify the worthiness of Muthoot finance in the market.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Finance World

Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd Earns EcoVadis 2023 Silver Medal

Published

on

By

In today’s dynamic stock market, sustainability has become a key factor for investors seeking long-term growth opportunities. One company that has recently garnered attention for its sustainability efforts is Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd. In this blog, we’ll explore why investing in Himadri can be a wise choice for those looking to align their portfolios with sustainability goals.

About Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd

Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd is a prominent player in the speciality chemical industry. They focus on research and development (R&D), innovation, and sustainability. The company is a pioneer in the production of lithium-ion battery materials in India. They constantly innovate raw materials for the lithium-ion battery value chain. Their diverse product range includes speciality carbon black, coal tar pitch, refined naphthalene, advanced materials, and more. Himadri serves various sectors such as lithium-ion batteries, paints, plastics, tires, aluminum, graphite electrodes, agrochemicals, defense, and construction chemicals.

Himadri operates both domestically and internationally. They export their products to 49 countries worldwide. The company’s strong commitment to sustainability is evident through its eight zero-liquid discharge manufacturing facilities. Additionally, they extensively use in-house clean power, covering over 90% of their energy needs. These initiatives highlight Himadri’s dedication to reducing its environmental footprint while maintaining robust business operations.

Himadri’s EcoVadis Silver Medal

In 2023, Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd achieved the prestigious Silver Medal from EcoVadis, a globally recognized agency for business sustainability ratings. This achievement signifies Himadri’s unwavering commitment to sustainability across crucial pillars. These pillars include governance/ethics, environment, labor and human rights, and sustainable procurement.

Stock has grown over 3.5 times over the past 12 months. The rally still looks intact. However, trading at around a PE of 43, investors should be careful.

This recognition places Himadri among the top 23% of companies evaluated by EcoVadis worldwide, a remarkable accomplishment considering that EcoVadis rates over 100,000 entities. Himadri’s commitment to sustainability extends to well-defined short-term and long-term objectives, each with specific timelines. The company is resolute in allocating the necessary resources—whether financial, technological, or research-driven—to meet these goals.

One noteworthy commitment is Himadri’s active pursuit of carbon neutrality by 2050. This aligns the company with global decarbonization objectives. These forward-thinking initiatives not only support environmental sustainability but also demonstrate the company’s readiness to embrace future regulatory changes and market demands.

Investing in Himadri for a Sustainable Future

Investing in Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd presents an exciting opportunity for those seeking sustainable investment options. As the world shifts toward more environmentally conscious practices, companies like Himadri are well-positioned to thrive. With its strong focus on R&D and innovation, Himadri is poised to tap into emerging markets and technologies. This includes the growing demand for lithium-ion batteries and other sustainable products.

Furthermore, Himadri’s commitment to corporate governance, ethical boundaries, and alignment with the United Nations Global Compact and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) showcases its dedication to responsible and sustainable business practices. This commitment is not only reassuring for investors but also contributes positively to the global push for a more sustainable future.

Follow Tradealone for more news on chemical sector.

In conclusion, Himadri Speciality Chemical Ltd’s EcoVadis Silver Medal is a testament to the company’s sustainability efforts and its potential as an investment opportunity. By prioritizing sustainability and innovation, Himadri is not only making a positive impact on the industry but also paving the way for a greener and more prosperous future. Investors with an eye on the long term and a commitment to sustainability should keep a close watch on this promising company.

Continue Reading

editor

HDFC Bank’s Future: A Realistic Take on Its Market Potential for next 20 years

Published

on

By

Private banks

Hello Financial Wizards! Let’s Talk HDFC Bank’s Future

Hey there, savvy investors and finance enthusiasts! Today, let’s dive into a hot topic that’s been stirring up the investment community – the future of HDFC Bank. Can it really grow 100x in the next 20 years? Some say yes, while others, including a former banker, are raising their eyebrows. Let’s break this down together. 💬🔍

A $16 Trillion Dream: Is It Really Possible?

So, here’s the deal: HDFC Bank currently sits at a market cap of around $160 billion. There’s talk about it reaching a staggering $16 trillion in 20 years. Mind-blowing, right? But let’s not get carried away just yet. 🌌💸

The Banking Battlefield: It’s Tough Out There!

The banking sector is like a gladiator arena. It’s ultra-competitive, and banks have to constantly up their game to keep customers happy. If they don’t, there’s always another bank ready to swoop in. And let’s not forget the threats from neobanks, online banks, credit unions… you name it. 🛡️🏦

HDFC Bank vs. The World of Digital Banking

Facing the Future Head-On

HDFC Bank has been a juggernaut, no doubt. But the world of banking is changing at a breakneck pace. We’re talking about digital revolutions with neobanks and online banking platforms. These players are rewriting the rules, making it tough for traditional banks to keep up. 🌐🚀

The Numbers Game: ROCE and Growth

HDFC’s Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) is currently around 6-7%. Now, here’s a nugget of wisdom from Charlie Munger: a stock’s long-term returns roughly equal its ROCE. So, if the capital compounds at 6%, how can we expect a 25% CAGR in market cap? It’s a head-scratcher, isn’t it? 🤔💹

Leverage and Growth: A Double-Edged Sword

Sure, HDFC has a higher Return on Equity (RoE) at 18% thanks to leverage. And yes, it can grow faster than its ROCE. But even then, expecting it to grow at an old rate of 25% seems like a stretch, especially given its size. 📈⚖️

A Reality Check: Comparing Global Giants

The US Economy and JP Morgan

Let’s play a game of comparison. Imagine India in 20 years, matching today’s US economy. The biggest bank in the US, JP Morgan, is valued at around $500 billion, not even close to $1 trillion. So, expecting HDFC Bank to reach $16 trillion seems… well, a tad overoptimistic. 🇮🇳🇺🇸

The Big Picture: India’s GDP and HDFC Bank

Think about it – India’s GDP itself might hit $30 trillion in 20 years. So, picturing a single company, even HDFC Bank, at a $16 trillion market cap is, to put it mildly, a stretch. 🌍💰

Wrapping Up: What’s the Smart Move?

As much as we love rooting for our favorite stocks, it’s crucial to stay grounded. In a world rapidly embracing new tech, even the mighty can struggle to outperform. So, as you strategize your investments, remember – the future is about adaptability, innovation, and realistic expectations. 🚀🧠


And there you have it, folks! What do you think about HDFC Bank’s future? Is it a golden goose or a reality check waiting to happen? Drop your thoughts and let’s keep this conversation going! 💬📊

Continue Reading

editor

Tata Technologies – Engineering a Better World and Stellar IPO Performance

tata technologies IPO

Published

on

Stock Market Returns

Engineering a Better World with Tata Technologies

Tata Technologies, an integral part of the esteemed Tata Group, stands as a transformative force in the engineering landscape, spearheading innovation at the dynamic crossroads of digital technology and traditional engineering. Specializing in pivotal industries such as automotive, aerospace, and industrial machinery, Tata Technologies assumes a critical role in the entire product development lifecycle. Tata Technologies just has a stellar IPO performance.

The company’s impact extends from the conceptualization phase, where groundbreaking ideas take shape, through the meticulous development process, and finally to the realization of cutting-edge products and experiences. Tata Technologies doesn’t merely contribute to technological advancement; it actively shapes a future where products are not only safer and more sustainable but also possess the transformative power to significantly enhance the quality of people’s lives.

Industries Tata Technologies is operating in:

In the automotive sector, Tata Technologies plays a crucial role in envisioning and creating vehicles that meet the evolving demands of the market. Whether it’s pioneering electric vehicles, enhancing safety features, or optimizing fuel efficiency, the company’s engineering prowess shines through.

In the aerospace industry, company takes flight by contributing to the development of innovative solutions that propel the sector forward. From designing state-of-the-art aircraft components to advancing aerospace technology, the company is at the forefront of progress.

In the realm of industrial heavy machinery, Tata Technologies leverages its expertise to engineer robust and efficient solutions. This involves developing machinery that not only meets industry standards but also incorporates the latest advancements in technology to enhance productivity and reliability.

Driving the Change:

As a trailblazer in the engineering domain, Tata Technologies not only adapts to change but actively drives it. Through a harmonious blend of digital innovation and traditional engineering principles, the company continues to inspire a new generation of engineers, fostering a spirit of creativity, collaboration, and excellence. In essence, Tata Technologies is not just a participant in the evolution of industries; it is a driving force behind the transformation of ideas into tangible, impactful realities.

Their approach goes beyond delivering discrete outcomes. Tata Technologies is a comprehensive partner for end-to-end product development, equipped with the experience and expertise to envision and materialize a better future. The company’s global presence brings together diverse teams with a variety of skill sets, collaborating in real-time to solve complex engineering problems. This collaborative effort is pivotal in redefining engineering and expanding its influence to address humanity’s most pressing challenges and opportunities.

Tata Technologies IPO: A Milestone Achievement

After 19 years, Tata Technologies, a gem in the Tata Group’s crown, celebrated a momentous milestone by going public. The IPO was met with overwhelming enthusiasm, reminiscent of the reception of TCS’s IPO, the last Tata Group company to go public.

  • IPO Details: The IPO was priced at Rs 500, but it listed at an astonishing Rs 1200, translating to a premium of 140%! The current market price stands at around Rs 1250.
  • Valuation: At the listing price of Rs 1200, the company commands a forward multiple of 67x (based on Rs 18 EPS) and a current PE of 72x.
  • Comparison with TCS: TCS’s IPO in July 2004 had a price band of ₹775-900 and was listed at a 26.6% premium. Fast forward to Tata Technologies, the company received 73.57 Lakh applications for its IPO, a striking number that even surpasses the 73.37 Lakh applications for the colossal LIC IPO.
  • Oversubscription: The IPO witnessed an oversubscription of 69 times, indicating the market’s strong confidence and elevated expectations for the company.

Celebrating the IPO Success

The IPO’s success story is not just about numbers; it’s a testament to Tata Technologies’ strong market position and promising future. A substantial profit of Rs 21,000 per lot had investors allotted shares celebrating, turning it into a highly successful listing event.

A Moment of Reflection

This remarkable journey of of the company and its astounding IPO performance brings a moment of reflection on the excitement and unpredictability of India’s IPO market. It’s a reminder of how applying for IPOs in such a dynamic market can sometimes feel like a lucky lottery.

Conclusion

Tata Technologies’ journey from engineering excellence to a stellar IPO is a narrative of innovation, growth, and market confidence. It’s a story that resonates with the Tata Group’s legacy and its ongoing commitment to shaping a better future through technology, engineering, and sustainable practices. However, there are still numerous high-potential stocks that are currently underperforming, and we recommend exploring these opportunities.


Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and is not a recommendation or endorsement for any financial investment or strategy.

Check out some other potential multibaggers with Tradealone.

Continue Reading

Trending